Readings from Psy Etc.

Rumination, when thoughts go round in circles

Edition of ArticleUpdated on

Rumination means repeatedly returning to a situation, a difficulty or what it seems to say about you, without reaching a new understanding or a useful action. Worries often concern what might happen, while rumination tends to revisit the past. These two forms of repetitive thinking can, however, overlap (Saulsman et al., 2015a).

A recurring thought is not, on its own, a diagnosis. What deserves attention is how much space it takes up, how difficult it is to disengage from it and how it affects everyday life. Resources from the Centre for Clinical Interventions (2023) discuss, among other things, the links between these thoughts, anxiety and sleep.

How can you tell it apart from useful reflection?

Useful reflection sometimes leads to a decision, a specific question or the realization that information is missing. Rumination can replay the same scenario with a few details changed, without changing what you can do. Saulsman et al. (2015b) distinguish solving a current problem from mentally repeating a worry.

After a meeting, for example, you might realize that your request was unclear and prepare a clarification for the next day. You have a possible action. Spending the whole evening replaying every expression on your colleagues’ faces to know for certain what they thought does not necessarily provide that information.

The distinction therefore lies less in the subject than in how you approach it. A financial concern deserves real attention. It can also become repetitive when the same calculation is done again without new information, at the expense of rest or a useful step.

Turn a concern into a specific problem

When action is possible, stating the problem concretely can help you move beyond broad questions. ‘I’m going to fail at everything’ offers little to work with. ‘I need a piece of information to finish this document’ makes it possible to decide whom to ask and when (Saulsman et al., 2015b).

Here is an illustrative example. Someone worries that they will not finish everything by Friday. They can clarify the expected task, check the actual deadline and ask which priority to keep. This does not guarantee a reasonable workload. It does make it possible to discuss a real constraint, rather than mentally seeking an assurance that cannot be obtained.

For a past situation, an action might be correcting a mistake or apologizing. When no repair is needed or possible, repeating the same analysis calls for a different response.

What can you do when no certain answer is available?

The NHS (n.d.) suggests distinguishing difficulties you can act on from hypothetical scenarios beyond your control. It also suggests setting aside a limited time for worries, instead of letting them interrupt every activity. You can try this without turning it into another rule you must get right.

You could write down a few words to remember the question, then return to what you were doing. You do not need to transcribe every thought. If the time set aside itself becomes a long checking session, or if this approach increases your distress, it is worth reviewing it with a professional.

The aim is to be able to postpone the analysis, even if uncertainty remains. Trying to eliminate every unpleasant thought can become another mental preoccupation. The guide by Saulsman et al. (2015a) instead suggests working on how you respond to thoughts when they arise.

Return to an activity without waiting to resolve everything

In an everyday example, someone replaying a conversation can notice what their mind is doing, then return to the recipe they were preparing or the conversation happening now. This does not settle what the other person was thinking. They are choosing where to direct their attention for the next few minutes.

This distinction connects with some of the ideas in our article on ACT and your relationship with difficult thoughts. Acknowledging that a thought is present does not mean believing it, approving of it or having to resolve it immediately.

An attention exercise may feel uncomfortable or simply not suit you. It can be adapted, shortened or set aside. General resources do not replace support that takes each person’s history and difficulties into account.

When should you seek support?

When repetitive thoughts disrupt work, sleep or relationships, you can talk about them without waiting to know what to call them. Bring a specific situation and its impact. ‘After a call, I reread my notes for an hour and can’t start anything else’ is an understandable starting point.

A consultation can explore anxiety, low mood or other associated difficulties. It can also help distinguish rumination from repeatedly seeking certainty or a mental ritual. Our page on individual therapy for adults describes the general setting for this support. Goals are based on the activities you would like to make more room for.

References

Centre for Clinical Interventions. (2023, 10 juillet). Worry and rumination. https://www.cci.health.wa.gov.au/Resources/Looking-After-Yourself/Worry-and-Rumination

NHS. (s. d.). Tackling your worries. https://www.nhs.uk/every-mind-matters/mental-wellbeing-tips/self-help-cbt-techniques/tackling-your-worries/

Saulsman, L., Nathan, P., Lim, L., Correia, H., Anderson, R. et Campbell, B. (2015a). What? Me worry!?! Mastering your worries: Overview of worrying (Module 2). Centre for Clinical Interventions. https://www.cci.health.wa.gov.au/~/media/CCI/Consumer-Modules/What-Me-Worry/What-Me-Worry---02---Overview-of-Worry.pdf

Saulsman, L., Nathan, P., Lim, L., Correia, H., Anderson, R. et Campbell, B. (2015b). What? Me worry!?! Mastering your worries: Problem-solving (Module 7). Centre for Clinical Interventions. https://www.cci.health.wa.gov.au/~/media/CCI/Consumer-Modules/What-Me-Worry/What-Me-Worry---07---Problem-Solving.pdf